Real Estate Counter Offers: What Sellers Should Know About Negotiations

Counteroffers in real estate can be a game-changer for anyone looking to sell their home. They occur when a buyer or seller is not fully satisfied with the original price and makes an offer of their own. This involves negotiation on various elements, including the sales price, closing costs, and specific terms of the sale. 

Understanding how to effectively engage in this process is essential for sellers to maximize their benefits and specific needs. It’s a crucial part of the real estate transaction, ensuring both buyer and seller reach a mutually beneficial agreement—but if it all seems too daunting, sellers can always turn to simpler negotiations with a cash buyer instead.

For informational purposes only. Always consult with a licensed real estate professional before proceeding with any real estate transaction.

Get a Cash Offer on Your Home With Cash Is King.

Want to skip the hassle of selling your home? We’ll make you a Guaranteed Cash offer. Get started now for free!

Get Started

Should a Seller Reject a Buyer’s Initial Offer?

Deciding whether to accept or reject a buyer’s first offer requires careful consideration. While it may be tempting for sellers to hold out for the highest price, outright rejection might not be the best choice. Understanding the motivations behind the offer and the current real estate market conditions can go a long way.

Sellers should evaluate the offer in relation to the property’s market value. There are instances where rejecting an original offer is justified, like if it’s substantially below the property’s fair market value or if the buyer’s financial qualifications raise concerns. In that case, it may be best to wait for more qualified buyers.

But in many cases, a lowball offer may simply be an opening negotiation tactic, and outright rejection could potentially alienate a serious buyer. A counteroffer can open a constructive dialogue that may lead to a mutually agreeable price. Additionally, considering the prevailing market conditions is crucial; in a buyer’s market, where inventory is high and demand is low, sellers may need to be more flexible.

Tips for Making a Counter Offer

If the seller has decided to send a counteroffer to the buyer, it’s important to give it some thought. They don’t want to negotiate too far down from what they’re willing to get for the home, but they also don’t want to stick to their original asking price so firmly that the buyer decides to go elsewhere. 

Sales Price Negotiations

From a seller’s standpoint, negotiating the price of the home is often the most critical aspect of a counter offer. When an offer on a home is below expectations, a seller may counter with a higher price. This can be the original asking price, signaling a limited willingness to negotiate, or a price between the asking and offer price, indicating openness to further talks. 

When sellers are in the process of adjusting the home’s price, it’s important to:

• Consider market conditions and property value
• Assess buyer interest and willingness to negotiate
• Balance higher price aspirations with the potential to lose the buyers

Striking a balance between all variables increases the chances that a deal can be made.

Closing Costs and Dates

Closing costs and dates are also pivotal in counteroffers. Buyers may ask the seller to cover some or all of these costs, potentially saving the buyer thousands of dollars. The closing date is equally important; maybe the seller wants a specific timeline to vacate the property or coordinate with the purchase of their next home. By negotiating these terms, sellers can ensure a smoother transition and potentially better financial outcomes.

Buyer & Seller Contingencies

Sellers also need to consider buyer-requested contingencies like home inspections, financing, and appraisal. While some are standard, others, such as the sale of the buyer’s current home, may be negotiable. Sellers should carefully assess these contingencies to balance risk and opportunity. There are also contingencies for sellers, such as their ability to buy a new home. These can let the seller back out of the offer without penalty, which gives them extra flexibility.

Should Sellers Reject or Accept a Counter Offer?

Sellers must be adept at deciding when to accept a counter offer and when to reject it. Accepting a counteroffer brings them that much closer to finishing the sale, but there are instances when withdrawing may be more beneficial, especially in scenarios where there are multiple offers. As with the first offer, sellers should consider the offer in the context of their situation and the real estate market. 

Evaluating the contingencies outlined in the counteroffer, such as inspection and financing conditions, is crucial. If the buyer’s requests are reasonable, it may be worth accepting. However, gauging the buyer’s commitment is also key, as a well-qualified buyer is more likely to proceed smoothly through the closing process. The buyer putting down a large earnest money deposit is a good indicator of their seriousness.

Why Getting a Cash Offer is Better

Selling a house for cash can offer several advantages over traditional home selling. Cash sales typically mean faster transactions, as there’s no need to wait for buyer mortgage approvals. Sellers also avoid the complexities and uncertainties of back-and-forth negotations, which can be time-consuming and stressful. Additionally, cash offers are often more attractive to sellers as they generally involve fewer contingencies and a quicker, more certain sale.

Not only do cash offers save you the trouble of the negotiations discussed above, but they take out much of the difficulties of selling a home. You don’t have to worry about real estate agent commissions or showings or even making repairs, as the home will often be bought as-is.

Understanding Counter Offers in Real Estate

Navigating the world of counteroffers in real estate is essential for sellers aiming for the best possible outcome in their home selling journey. The strategic importance of understanding and effectively handling counter offers on a house can’t be overstated. 

However, it’s also key to remember that cash offers are always an option. If you don’t want to spend the time and effort negotiating with buyers—especially if they don’t see the value of your home—then selling to a cash buyer may be a great alternative.

For informational purposes only. Always consult with a licensed real estate professional before proceeding with any real estate transaction.